advertisement


FIND
Jobs Search Jobs $100k+ Jobs Dating Single men Single Women Cars New cars Used cars IE9IE9 Download IE9 now FatsoFatso Movies Rent DVDs
Readers recommend...
VIRAL VIDEOS
Star Wars spoof: Dog Strikes BackStar Wars spoof: Dog Strikes Back Ferris Bueller makes a comeback for Super BowlFerris Bueller makes a comeback for Super Bowl Faux ad: Fotoshop by AdobeFaux ad: Fotoshop by Adobe
Hot Topics on MSN NZ:
Supergiant crustacean Snooki pregnant Facebook headquarters

Should abusive parents get paid to be sterilised?

02:00 Thu Mar 4 2010
MSN NZ
Abusive parents should be offered a $5000 incentive to get sterilised, according to ACT MP David Garrett

Abusive parents should be offered a $5000 incentive to get sterilised, according to ACT MP David Garrett.

Garrett expresses his personal opinion, not representative of the ACT party, on a blog, according to media reports.

The blog discussed violence and death in families and the measures taken to prevent it from happening.

"If - say - $5000 was paid to the likes of both parents of the Kahui twins if they chose to be sterilised, this would address many ... concerns," Mr Garrett commented.

Three-month-old south Auckland twins Chris and Cru Kahui were killed four years ago and their father, Chris, was acquitted of their murders in 2008.

Anti-violence group Jigsaw spokesman Tau Huirama likened Garrett's rants to Hitler.

"I just cringe at the thought of sterilisation, it's a thing that takes you back to Hitler and that sort of thinking," he told Radio New Zealand.

Labour deputy leader Annette King opposed the idea and suggested the money would be better off used towards preventative measures such as parenting programmes.

Should parents with a history of abuse be offered a cash incentive to get sterilised? Have your say below.

User comments
This is a delicate subject for many parents. There are parents who have tried their best to be good enough parents and there are kids that are born with challenging behaviours and parents are not equipped to manage these difficult behaviours. There are many parenting skills programme available to parents, some you have to pay yourself and this is where the government could enforce these education groups and provide these programme FREE to parents and caregivers. Do we have a data of how many parents that have abused or are facing charges that have been offered these programme.It is easy to point a finger at parents and caregivers, we also need to stop and think whether we have done enough to reach out to these parents who needed help. Child abuse is a serious concern and unless the government and the community work together we will get no where and our children are suffering. Show us some raw data of parents that benefit from parenting programme and lets be positive about this
Yo i agree then we can use the dead brats name to forge passports an that would make us beter parents
What a joke!!!! What the government fail to realise, is that giving your kid a smack, is what prevents crime. If parents were allowed to smack their kids when they did wrong, they would learn. No-one is allowed to chastise their children. and then people want to kno why the kids of today are so faulty. Go figure!!!! Catch a wake up New Zealand, you are destroying your own country, by letting the government dictate to you. Face reality, cos our parents brought us up with a smack here and there, but the crime has got out of hand because laws have changed.
no I do not believe people should be payed for assaulting there children by being sterilised.that is another easy way for them to make money. Sorry I can't call them parents
what in the world is my country coming to? what happens to politicians who abuse their parliamentary privileges? involved in sex scandals? why don't you just sterlise every child who is born, that way, you don't have to wait around for the crime to be committed. our country is teetering on the brink of anarchy. not enough money to go around and you want to pay someone $5000 to get themselves sterilised. $5000 to get sterilised when people are getting laid off and you want to clamp down on beneficiaries. politicians get a wage rise immediately when they want to and a lot of free or very cheap perks. you have the audacity to degrade those less fortunate than you? i am almost ashamed to call myself a kiwi.
Perhaps Eugenics was a good idea?
I believe that they have given up all of their human rights once they abuse a child in any form. I do not believe we should pay them, just do it!!! Yes it wouldn't stop these monsters and bullies from hurting step children and my question is...can't vascetomies (spelling sorry) be reversed? Wouldn't that mean there is a need for another procedure to ensure it can't be reversed? As for the mothers honestly how can you let some bully hurt your children and all because you want a male in your life (I refuse to call them men). I believe all child abusers included those who fail to protect the child when they know abuse is occuring need to be dealt with harshly. Perhaps a break the cycle approach needs to be thought of. I wish there was a magical answer to stop all this, but I know there isn't. Women wake up and protect your kids, if you don't who will? They are your responsibility and in most cases there first. They come first!!!
No, we see hundreds of poor people do stupid crimes to get out of relationships, financial stress etc just to receive free rent, food and new criminal friends as well as a tax payer paid education leading to a hopefully better criminal life and reputation. This will have criminal minds deliberately abusing their children to get a financial gain. However as proved many woman are deliberately having children for financial gain with out any future plans with their male victims anyway. Thus destroying more lives and possibly now enticing their partners to punish their children.
No, we see hundreds of poor people do stupid crimes to get out of relationships, financial stress etc just to receive free rent, food and new criminal friends as well as a tax payer paid education leading to a hopefully better criminal life and reputation. This will have criminal minds deliberately abusing their children to get a financial gain. However as proved many woman are deliberately having children for financial gain with out any future plans with their male victims anyway. Thus destroying more lives and possibly now enticing their partners to punish their children.
I'm an aunty of 8 beautiful boys and 3 gorgeous girls and unfortunately I can't have any babies of my own. I would love to be a mum and to have people out there who doesn't deserve children is a cruel and harsh reality for me. I wish they did have this as punishment for them. They shouldn't be allowed to bring anymore children into the world.

Most popular videos
Tension Grows At WaitangiTension Grows At Waitangi Security Breach At SevensSecurity Breach At Sevens NZ To Play ENG In Semi-FinalNZ To Play ENG In Semi-Final Interview with Ronan KeatingInterview with Ronan Keating Early Casualty For New Zealand SevensEarly Casualty For New Zealand Sevens