advertisement


FIND
Jobs Search Jobs $100k+ Jobs Dating Single men Single Women Cars New cars Used cars IE9IE9 Download IE9 now FatsoFatso Movies Rent DVDs
Readers recommend...
VIRAL VIDEOS
Star Wars spoof: Dog Strikes BackStar Wars spoof: Dog Strikes Back Ferris Bueller makes a comeback for Super BowlFerris Bueller makes a comeback for Super Bowl Faux ad: Fotoshop by AdobeFaux ad: Fotoshop by Adobe
Hot Topics on MSN NZ:
Supergiant crustacean Snooki pregnant Facebook headquarters

Should celebrities get name suppression?

02:00 Thu Nov 19 2009
MSN NZ staff

Justice Minister Simon Power wants to see famous people receive the same treatment as everyone else when in court.

Mr Power told the New Zealand Herald a halt should be placed on the emerging "special class" of high-profile people who use their status to attain name suppression.

Read more: Power seeks hard line on court secrecy for celebs

He was responding to a Law Commission report released earlier this week which said well-known people should still be able to argue for suppression if publication would cause "extreme hardship".

Mr Power believes no special rights should be allowed.

"Anybody who makes an application for name suppression should be dealt with on the same grounds, regardless of whether they think they are well known," he said.

"Whether or not somebody believes they are well known, it should not be a ground in itself for name suppression being granted."

The Law Commission's report places onus for the decision to be left to the judge’s discretion.

This month a "prominent entertainer" who forced a teenage girl's face into his genitals was granted permanent suppression to avoid a detrimental effect on his career, including record and ticket sales.

Other cases of "celebrity justice" include the 2005 controversy when an All Black was granted permanent name secrecy despite having pleaded guilty to assaulting his pregnant partner.

Should celebrities be treated like any other criminal in court? Or is that unfair because there is so much more media interest when court cases involve famous people? Have your say below.

User comments
reading through all comments put on here says that no to keeping their name suppresed from the public is crap they did the crime and like everyone else do the time and what goes with that crime I say (NO)
I agree that a successful application for permanent name suppression should be based upon case, by case merit rather than who you are or arent. My feeling is that up until a day in court or an actual criminal trial is met, that every person should have some level of anonomity until they are proven guilty and therefore shall be named. I think people are far too caught up with and fearful about is the thought that "Oh my they're a Celeb... They'll get away with it!" The inevitable occurs, and people lose faith in the legal system and those charged with it. I think New Zealanders are fed up and 'Justice-Driven' to a point where they have had enough of Celebrity or 'Special Case' people cruising through our legal system as a result of their special status, with their status often clouding the actual case. Whillst on the other hand 'Ordinary' mortals are torn relentlessly apart by our legal system for something as small as stealing to feed a starving family.
Why are they any differant from the rest of us, what have thay got that we haven,t print there names in big bold letters
why shouldnt they? they just like everybody else except one thing.....money! thats all it is! if we do a crime people go on about it for months when the SPECIAL PEOPLE arent even being named! when it comes to crimes EVERYBODY should be treated the same reguardless of race,sex,colour AND money!!!!!
Noooooooooooooooo, Hell No!!! they are not special!!!!
Every person who commits a crime should be exposed and not protected, at present the law protects the abuser and has no respect and or consideration for the victims. Sports celeberties as well POlice and the law totally supports footballer Renee Ranger smashing over young people in this area and allowing him to go free. When is the law going to do its job well and take a look at the victims and the cost to the victim, which ACC has to pay for their damage.
No, Why should they get name suppression, there no different than the rest of us, thet have two arms and two legs, if they can't do the time don't do the crime.
Why give them special treatment not to be named. Do the crime, do the time
We dont need to know every tom *** and harry story. Celebs do what they do because they are good at it and sometimes do stupid things that WE ALL do, and why the hell does the whole world need to know.
No way.....they should be treated as anyone normal person. A crime is a crime, no matter who committed it.

Most popular videos
Tension Grows At WaitangiTension Grows At Waitangi Security Breach At SevensSecurity Breach At Sevens NZ To Play ENG In Semi-FinalNZ To Play ENG In Semi-Final Interview with Ronan KeatingInterview with Ronan Keating Early Casualty For New Zealand SevensEarly Casualty For New Zealand Sevens